“Key Man” = “Great Man” – Part I

In leadership no debate is livelier and more long-lived than the one about “the Great Man.”*

Here in a nutshell is the argument:

  • In 1841 the Scottish writer and philosopher, Thomas Carlyle, insisted that nothing and no one mattered more than the great man, the great leader. For as I take it, Universal History, the history of what man has accomplished in this world, is at bottom the History of the Great Men who have worked here.
  • In 1873 Carlyle was derided by esteemed British sociologist Herbert Spencer, who took on his even more esteemed predecessor. But now… we demand that our ideas shall be brought into focus and exactly defined, we discover that [Carlyle’s] hypothesis [is] utterly incoherent…. We find that his theory breaks down completely.
  • In 1943 the American philosopher Sidney Hook distinguished between the “eventful man” and the “event-making man.” The former he defined as a leader whose actions influenced subsequent developments along a quite different course than would have been followed if these actions had not been taken. The latter in contrast was a leader whose actions are the consequences of outstanding capacities of intelligence, will and character rather than accidents of position.**   

Fast forward and we land on the now ubiquitous former CEO of Nvidia, Jensen Huang. In recent days Huang has been widely described not as a “great man” but as a “key man.” Descriptors that it turns out, are effectively one and the same.

“Key man” is not a term with which most of us were previously familiar. But the “key man clause” is known to experts in corporate governance – the “key man” being the equivalent of what Carlyle called the great man.  

According to the Corporate Finance Institute a key man is “an important employee or executive who is critical to the operation of the business, and whose death, absence, or disability may have a significant negative effect on the operation of a company. Key people possess skills, knowledge, leadership abilities, and experience that are considered crucially important for the continued success of the business.”  In short, “key men” are “great men.” They are leaders who if, for whatever reason, disappear from one moment to the next, leave their followers bereft. Leave their followers flailing to find the successor who can come closest to filling the great man’s shoes.  

No group or organization should be left in this position. How it happened that Huang made himself indispensable, how it happened that his followers enabled him to become a key man, will be discussed in my next post.  

*Let’s just say that then as now most leaders were/are men.

**For more on this classic debate, as well as on the classics of the leadership literature generally, see Barbara Kellerman, (ed.) Leadership: Essential Selections on Power, Authority, and Influence (McGraw-Hill, 2010).

Posted in: Digital Article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *